Log in

No account? Create an account
25 February 2010 @ 12:43 pm
lims round one, challenge two - results  
And here are the results!... I'm sorry to see one of ou guys go, but don't worry! There will be a comeback challenge :))


rainbowishes with 3 votes.

People's Choice:

chacusha and caramelmilk_t with 3 votes.

The next challenge will be posted on Friday - this way you will have the whole week to make your icons and the voting will be posted next Saturday.
Here are the tallies. You can check your icon number here.

Negative votes:
icon #1
> The coloring is a bit too strong.
> The coloring looks a little too saturated. And Meg looks a little grainy. Becides that, it's a beautiful icon.
> texture overwhelms the icon.

icon #2
> I think the image isn't cut off well. especially the hair and the moon looks odd to me.
> While generally this icon is well made, the stock background doesn't really fit well with the chosen subject. I'd blame that on the fact that the moon is, technically, "real" while the Disney couple is not. A different background choice, perhaps? Maybe a pattern or some scenery that looks less real would have complimented the couple better

icon #3

icon #4
> I think the icon is very well made but I think there's too many textures going on. Honestly, I can't really put my finger on it but out of the three icons, I would pick this one for lesser quality.

Positive votes:
icon #1
> I really love the colouring. It's quite extreme but it makes the icon look very magical and the clouds and the texture fit together perfectly.

icon #2

icon #3
> I think the texture use is spectacular. I love how tiny the figures are, and you still can tell who are the characters.
> The cropping with the negative space makes this a powerful, emotional and beautiful icon.
> brilliant! the colors and the negative space is so beautiful! and I think the contrast is perfect!

icon #4
> Original, fresh crop and smooth coloring.
> I love the choice of textures, colouring, the clarity of image! Gorgeous :))
> Fantastic crop and cap choice. The coloring is nicely done as well.

Tako: :ochacusha on February 25th, 2010 03:30 pm (UTC)
Oh wow, I'm actually a little surprised by my comments since I only used one texture in the entire icon! Oh well, I guess it's hard to tell. Thanks for people's choice!
Sophiecaramelmilk_t on February 25th, 2010 08:04 pm (UTC)
Ack! That's my mistake... I actually meant to vote for 2 for lesser quality but somehow I wrote 4.
Sophiecaramelmilk_t on February 25th, 2010 08:05 pm (UTC)
Thank you everyone. =)